Challenge
A small Critical Access Hospital (CAH) faced severe financial and operational headwinds. Years of underinvestment had led to deteriorating infrastructure, and its aging, understaffed clinical team struggled to keep up with community needs. Despite these challenges, the hospital board believed the organization had untapped potential and sought a partner who could help sustain and expand services. The challenge was to quantify that potential in a way that prospective affiliates would recognize and value.
Approach
The hospital engaged Stroudwater to analyze the CAH’s current financial and operational performance and to identify and quantify its accretive value to a potential partner. Rather than focusing solely on cost containment, Stroudwater evaluated home office cost allocation, eligibility and structure of the 340B program opportunity, swing bed capacity and performance, and potential referral volume shifts. Notably, Stroudwater excluded additional upside opportunities such as improved admissions from the emergency department or enhanced performance in the rural health clinics (RHCs) to provide a conservative, credible value proposition for this prospective rural affiliate.
Findings
Stroudwater’s analysis revealed that the CAH could drive $670,000 in annual performance improvement based on better cost allocation, drug pricing opportunities under 340B, and optimized use of its swing bed program. Further modeling showed that by increasing referrals to a partner organization by just 2–4%, the CAH could generate an additional $991,000 to $1.98 million in accretive value. These numbers were particularly compelling because they excluded additional RHC optimization opportunities or other operational improvements.
Outcome
Armed with a detailed and credible valuation report, the CAH entered a competitive affiliation process. The clarity provided by the analysis enabled the hospital to engage in negotiations from a position of strength. Ultimately, the organization secured an affiliation with a larger community hospital that committed to investing in infrastructure, expanding service lines, and preserving core programs locally.
Impact
This partnership accomplished far more than just preserving the hospital—it positioned the CAH for future growth and resilience. The community retained access to essential services, the medical staff saw renewed support, and the partner organization gained a clearly defined, financially beneficial rural affiliate. This case illustrates how rural expertise and data-driven insight can shift the trajectory of a distressed CAH and enable mutually beneficial partnerships.
To learn more about working with Stroudwater’s partnerships team, click here.
